Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous | Next

I know I have friends on my list that are in OK. I would like to ask you to help, as this is something very near and dear to me. To sum it up, there is a bill being passed around right now called GINA - The Genetic Information Non-Discrimination Act. GINA protects those of us who choose to get genetic testing from being discriminated against by employers, insurers or others based on our results.

To give you an example - I had genetic testing and was found to have a BRCA2 genetic mutation that increased my chance for breast cancer. Based on my family history, along with this mutation, there is nothing that really protects me from my insurer (who covered the test) deciding I was 'high-risk' and refusing to cover me were I to get breast cancer. My employer could have gotten that information and decided I wasn't a good bet for a long-term employee.

Thankfully, my insurance company was helpful, and while they did NOT pay for any of the genetic testing (which is damn expensive) they DID pay 100% of my decision to go ahead with prophylactic measures to avoid ovarian and breast cancer in the future. Many may not be so lucky, especially if they are in lower-income jobs with minimal health insurance.

Here is the information from FORCE (Facing our Risk for Cancer Empowered - a group for individuals who are high-risk for breast or other cancers):

I received the following update and alert on the Genetic Information
Nondiscrimination Act! Please read below and take the appropriate
action (if you live in Oklahoma call Senator Coburn and if you live
elsewhere call Senators Lott and McConnell). This is unbelievable that
we are so close yet so far. We need your help, please act today!!!!

Your phone calls to your senators resulted in almost all senators
agreeing to vote yes for GINA! But Senator Colburn of OK has placed a
hold on the bill, which means it cannot be voted on until he releases
his hold.

If you are from OK (please pass this on to OK residents too):
Call Senator Colburn and ask him to release his hold, and to vote YES
for GINA:
Tom Coburn (R-OK) Phone 202.224.5754
Fax 202.224.6008

Everyone else else, please call the Republican leadership in the Senate
- Trent Lott (MS), Republican Whip and Mitch McConnell (KY), Republican
Leader and tell them you want to see the bill come to the floor today,
and you'd like them to ask Senator Colburn to release his hold.
Trent Lott (R-MS) Phone 202.224.6253
Fax 202.224.2262
Mitch McConnell (R-KY) Phone 202.224.2541
Fax 202.224.2499

Thank you all for your work. I know this is a great deal to ask after
yesterday, but we are almost there. Please turn up the heat right away
so that the Senate can pass GINA!! After all, it passed it unanimously
twice before, and this time the language has been agreed on by all of
the members (Democrats and Republicans) of all of the committees of
jurisdiction in both the House and the Senate. We have a bipartisan
bill with unanimous support, except for this hold. Let's get it done!


( 4 thoughts — Whatcha' think? )
Jul. 25th, 2007 04:15 pm (UTC)
My question is why is it so narrowly drafted? Why not protect anyone who comes back with a bad test result - like HIV or Hep C? Shouldn't all discrimination be banned?
Jul. 25th, 2007 09:19 pm (UTC)
I think they have narrowed it to distinguish genetic discrimination apart from other medical discrimination. Yes, all medical discrimination should be banned, but this is one of those 'new concepts' that has no precedent to fall back on. HIV (don't know about Hep C, but think it MIGHT, not being a lawyer myself, also be looked at as a 'medical condition you have tested positive for') has been tried in court for discrimination. Genetic discrimination only has a small distinguisher - you aren't actually POSITIVE for anything. You don't HAVE a disease, just the predisposition for it.

As they map more and more genes that are responsible for different diseases, maybe even HIV, Autism, arthritis, other conditions, this opens the door for a legal stance against genetic discrimination in those areas.
Jul. 26th, 2007 12:52 am (UTC)
The Republicans believe we should "let market forces decide" and the government should not be involved in such things. Hence, I suspect trying to get those senators you mention (Coburn; Lott; McConnell) to do ANYTHING about this is a waste of time, sadly. Best of luck to you, but ... don't get your hopes up.
Aug. 8th, 2007 03:26 pm (UTC)
respectfully disagree
Only a handful of Republicans subscribe to the ideology you posted. Most Republicans, especially those on Capitol Hill, are not unlike Democrats in that they vote for things that are likely to get them re-elected.

That being said: Coburn is a self-described maverick/martyr and no one really knows why he has issues with this bill or the other 14 bills upon which he has holds placed. Coburn for some reason will not listen to his constituents. He wants to blaze his own path and OK is responsible for that, OK elected him.

This bill should be passed, it should have passed over 10 years ago. Discrimination should not be governed by the market. If so, we have no civil rights bills or more than half of the Constitution.
( 4 thoughts — Whatcha' think? )